Two hunters, one obsession.

We're Nick & Aiyana. What started as weekend walks on the beach turned into a full-blown fossil obsession — and now, a shop.

Fossil shark teeth found by Nick and Aiyana

It started with a single shark tooth on Folly Beach — small, black, perfect. We were hooked. Since then we've spent countless weekends wading through South Carolina rivers, scanning creek beds after storms, and learning to read the ground like a history book.

Our collection grew faster than our shelves. Friends started asking to buy pieces. Then friends of friends. So here we are: Sweet Tooth Fossils, selling the fossils we find with our own hands.

Why "sweet tooth"? Because nothing beats the feeling of spotting that perfect triangle glinting in the gravel. It's a sweet tooth for ancient teeth.

The authenticity promise

Found by us

Every fossil in this shop was found by Nick or Aiyana — never bought in bulk, never imported mystery stock.

Never repaired

No glued tips, no sculpted roots, no composites. What you see is exactly what the earth made.

Full refund guarantee

If any qualified expert tells you a piece isn't genuine, we refund you completely. No fine print.

Say hello

Questions about a fossil, hunting tips, or just want to talk teeth? We answer everything ourselves.

Message us

Use the "Ask a question" button on any fossil page and we'll reply personally, usually the same day.

Browse the fossils
Local pickup

In the Charleston, SC area? Choose local pickup at checkout and we'll arrange a handoff — no shipping fees.